| 2020 | Dan Fucella - 33 Lbs. | Nicole Gains - 13 Lbs. | None entered |
| 2019 | Steve Knapik- 38 Lbs. | Steve Trogele - 15 Lbs | None entered |
| 2018 | Corneilus Mcguire - 34 lbs. | Bill Davison - 19 lbs. | None entered |
| 2017 | John Citarella - 29 lbs. | Mike Campanelli - 18 lbs. | None entered |
| 2016 | Billy Leuck - 38 lbs. | Rick Zappala / Jim Jaget / Steve Trogele - 18 lbs. | None entered |
| 2015 | Matt Ianotti - 38 lbs. | Matt Ianotti/Bill Davison/John Citarella - 18 lbs | Rick Zappala - 5 lbs |
| 2014 | Rick Zappala - 30.82 lbs. | Bill Davison - 17.7 Lbs. | None entered |
| 2013 | Chris Sippel - 30.00 lbs. | Rick Zappala - 16 lbs. | Rick Zappala - 6 lbs. |
| 2012 | Steve Knapik - 32.26 lbs, | Charles DeVerna / Chris Sippel - 14 lbs. | None entered |
| 2011 | Rick Zappala - 23 lbs. | Bill Davison - 17 lbs. | None entered |
| 2010 | Bill Davison - 31 lbs. | John Citarella - 15 lbs. | Charles Deverna - 7 lbs. |
| 2009 | Bill Davison - 39.8 lbs. | Frank Miale - 14 lbs. | None entered |
| 2008 | John Citarella - 36 lbs. | Rick Zappala - 14 lbs. | None entered |
| 2007 | Jim Coucoulas - 26 lbs. | John Citarella - 15 lbs. | Jim Coucoulas - 13 lbs. |
| 2006 | Rob Lucia - 31 lbs. | John Citarella - 14 lbs. | Steve Knapik - 9 lbs. |
| 2005 | Jim Coucoulas - 32 lbs | John O'Keefe - 15 lbs | None entered |
| 2004 | Steve Knapik - 26 lbs. | George Kelnhofer - 14 lbs. | Jim Coucoulas - 10 lbs. |
| 2003 | George Kelnhofer - 27 lbs. | John O'Keefe - 14 lbs. | John O'Keefe -8 lbs. |
| 2002 | John Citarella - 38.8 lbs | George Kelnhofer - 17 lbs. | George Kelnhofer - 7 lbs. 8 oz. |
| 2001 | Peter Alamilla - 31 lbs. | John O'Keefe - 13 lbs. 11 oz. | John O'Keefe - 7 lbs. |
| 2000 | Jonathan Wagner - 33 lbs. | John Citarella - 15 lbs. | John Citarella - 8lbs. 8 oz. |
| 1999 | John Wagner - 32 lbs. | Jim Callahan - 16 lbs | None entered |
| 1998 | John Wagner - 29 lbs. | | None entered |
| 1997 | John Citarella - 33 lbs. / John Lindner - 35 lbs. ESB | | None entered |
| 1996 | Jack Driscoll - 32 lbs | Greg Nooney - 16 lbs. | None entered |
| 1995 | | | None entered |
| 1994 | Jack Driscoll - 35 lbs. | | None entered |
| 1993 | Greg Nooney - 48.12 lbs | Tom Cassino - 17 lbs. 6 oz. | None entered |
| 1992 | Bob Sicker - 22 lbs / Tom Cassino - 31 lbs. ESB | | None entered |
| 1991 | Jack Driscoll - 22 lbs. / Greg Nooney - 22 lbs. | | None entered |
| 1990 | Tony Iesu - 50.05 lbs. | | None entered |
| 1989 | Many Moreno - 25 lbs. 10 oz. | | None entered |
| 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
